Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.



 
HomeHome  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  GamesGames  Log in  

 

 Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011

Go down 
Go to page : 1, 2  Next

Best recruiters?
Broncos
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Bulldogs
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap29%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 29% [ 7 ]
Raiders
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Sharks
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Titans
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Sea Eagles
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Storm
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap8%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 8% [ 2 ]
Warriors
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Knights
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Cowboys
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap42%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 42% [ 10 ]
Eels
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap13%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 13% [ 3 ]
Panthers
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap4%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 4% [ 1 ]
Dragons
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Rabbitohs
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Roosters
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap0%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 0% [ 0 ]
Tigers
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_lcap4%Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Vote_rcap
 4% [ 1 ]
Total Votes : 24
 

AuthorMessage
Brenton
Guru
Brenton

Posts : 6699

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 1:24 pm

Quote :
Brisbane Broncos

Gain: Ben Hannant (Bulldogs)

Loss: Israel Falou (Greater Western Sydney - AFL), Antonio Winterstein (Cowboys), Ashton Sims (Cowboys), Tariq Sims (Cowboys), Korbin Sims (Knights)

Canterbury Bankstown Bulldogs

Gain: Aiden Tolman (Storm), Trent Hodkinson (Eagles), Kris Keating (Eels), Frank Pritchard (Panthers), Grant Millington (Sharks), Jonathan Wright (Eels), Michael Lett (Dragons), Greg Eastwood (Leeds Rhinos)

Loss: Ben Hannant (Broncos), Luke Patten (Salford), Blake Green (Hull KR), Brett Kimmorley (Retirement), Daniel Harrison (Eagles), Jarrad Hickey (Released), Danny Williams (Released), Tim Winitana (Panthers), Yileen Gordon (Panthers)

Canberra Raiders

Gain: Brett White (Storm), Blake Ferguson (Sharks)

Loss: Justin Carney (Roosters), Troy Thompson (Storm), Brett Kelly (Avignon Bisons), Adam Mogg (Retirement), Marc Herbert (Bradford Bulls)

Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks

Gain: Wade Graham (Panthers), Jeremy Smith (Dragons), Colin Best (Rabbitohs), John Williams (Cowboys), Ryan Tongia (Titans)

Loss: Luke Covell (Retirement), Blake Ferguson (Raiders), Trent Barrett (Retirement), Grant Millington (Bulldogs), Josh Lewis (Toulouse Olympique), Kyle O'Donnell (Newcastle Knights), Adam Cuthbertson (Panthers)

Gold Coast Titans

Gain: Luke Capewell (Rabbitohs)

Loss: Mat Rogers (Retirement), Jordan Atkins (Eels), Ryan Tongia (Sharks)

Manly Sea Eagles

Gain: Daniel Harrison (Bulldogs), Liam Foran (Roosters)

Loss: Trent Hodkinson (Bulldogs), Josh Perry (St. Helens), Ben Farrar (Catalan Dragons), Lama Tasi (Roosters), Chris Bailey (Harlequins)

Melbourne Storm

Gain: Adam Woolnough (Retirement), Troy Thompson (Raiders), Maurice Blair (Panthers), Jaiman Lowe (Rabbitohs), Elijah Niko (New Zealand Warriors)

Loss: Aiden Tolman (Bulldogs), Jeff Lima (Wigan), Ryan Hoffman (Wigan), Brett Finch (Wigan), Brett White (Raiders), Greg Inglis (Rabbitohs), Willie Isa (Released), Luke MacDougall (Released), Hep Cahill (Released), Blake Leary (Cowboys)

New Zealand Warriors

Gain: Krsinan Inu (Eels), Feleti Mateo (Eels), Steve Rapira (Cowboys)

Loss: Brent Tate (Cowboys), Ian Henderson (Les Catalans), Patrich Ah Van (Bradford Bulls), Siuatonga Likiliki (Knights), Nafe Seluini (Panthers), Elijah Niko (Storm)

Newcastle Knights

Gain: Neville Costigan (Dragons), Steve Southern (Cowboys), Beau Henry (Dragons), Siuatonga Likiliki (Warriors), Kyle O'Donnell (Sharks), Korbin Sims (Broncos)

Loss: Cooper Vuna (Melbourne Rebels), Steve Simpson (Retirement), Scott Dureau (Catalan Dragons), Ben Cross (Leeds)

North Queensland Cowboys

Gain: Antonio Winterstein (Broncos), Brent Tate (Warriors), Kalifa Fai-Fai Loa (Dragons), Ashton Sims (Broncos), Ricky Thorby (Dragons), Gavin Cooper (Panthers), Dallas Johnson (Les Catalans), Josh Bateman (Panthers), Tariq Sims (Broncos), Blake Leary (Storm), Tyson Martin (QLD Cup)

Loss: Steve Rapira (Warriors), Anthony Watts (Roosters), Luke O'Donnell (Huddersfield), Carl Webb (Eels), Willie Mason (Hull KR), Arana Taumata (Panthers), John Williams (Sharks), Ty Williams (Retirement), Donald Malone (Released), Obe Geia (Released),

Parramatta Eels

Gain: Carl Webb (Cowboys), Reni Maitua (Suspension), Jordan Atkins (Titans), Casey McGuire (Catalans Dragons).

Loss: Krisnan Inu (Warriors), Feleti Mateo (Warriors), Jonathan Wright (Bulldogs), Nathan Cayless (Retirement),

Penrith Panthers

Gain: Arana Taumata (Cowboys), Nafe Seluini (Warriors), Brendon Gibb (Norths Devil), Yileen Gordon (Bulldogs), Tim Winitana (Bulldogs), Adam Cuthbertson (Sharks)

Loss: Wade Graham (Sharks), Frank Pritchard (Bulldogs), Gavin Cooper (Cowboys), Maurice Blair (Storm), Daniel Penese (Dragons), Josh Bateman (Cowboys)

St George Illwarra Dragons

Gains: Daniel Penese (Panthers)

Loss: Jarrod Saffy (Melbourne Rebels - Union), Neville Costigan (Knights), Kalifa Fai-Fai Loa (Cowboys), Jeremy Smith (Sharks), Ricky Thorby (Cowboys), Michael Lett (Bulldogs), Beau Henry (Knights), Luke Priddis (Retirement)

South Sydney Rabbitohs

Gain: Greg Inglis (Storm)

Loss: Colin Best (Sharks), Jaiman Lowe (Storm), Luke Capewell (Titans), Garret Crossman (retired)

Sydney Roosters

Gain: Justin Carney (Raiders), Anthony Watts (Cowboys), Lama Tasi (Eagles),

Loss: JP Du Plessis (Melbourne Rebels), Lopini Paea (Catalan Dragons), Sam Brunton (Sacked), Nick Kouparitsas (Harlequins), James Aubusson (Goulburn), Liam Foran (Eagles)

Wests Tigers

Gain: -

Loss: -

Which teams do you think have recruited well and which teams do you think have recruited poorly? Which club has recruited the best?


Last edited by Brenton on Thu Nov 11, 2010 1:27 pm; edited 1 time in total
Back to top Go down
SBW
Guru
SBW

Posts : 3134

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 1:26 pm

So whats the poll question? Best, or worst? haha
Back to top Go down
Brenton
Guru
Brenton

Posts : 6699

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 1:26 pm

Best lol
Back to top Go down
SBW
Guru
SBW

Posts : 3134

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 1:28 pm

The Dogs have made some good signings, whether that leads to success or not is another question. I think the Knights have been really smart as well.
Back to top Go down
Danger32
Legend
Danger32

Posts : 10081
Location : Adelaide

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 1:29 pm

Panthers haven't improved their squad at all imo. Titans and Manly are the same. Dragons didn't need to. Cows or Dogs for best.
Back to top Go down
Brenton
Guru
Brenton

Posts : 6699

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 1:32 pm

Rabbits have done a good job, basically replacing Best with GI, and dropping three reserve graders. The Cowboys and Bulldogs have also done a great job. Warriors didn't do too bad but could of done better

For the worst (not including the Storm and Dragons with Gaz) I must say Parra. If they sign Tonga that will make their recruitment look half-decent but at the moment it's terrible.
Back to top Go down
Seaeagles
Guru
Seaeagles

Posts : 4608
Location : Sydney

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 1:38 pm

Dogs for me. They have strengthened most areas of their team, particularly their pack which should be very strong with some good players fighting for starting spots. Knights and Cowboys aren't too far behind either.

Worst is probably Parra, but we won't know how their signings will go until they actually play, a new coach could get the best out of them.
Back to top Go down
Scotty
Guru
Scotty

Posts : 1559
Age : 31
Location : Townsville

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 2:08 pm

Parra for worst, how any club could sign Webb, Walker, Fa'alago, Maitua and McGuire is beyond me, plus Manuakafoa in the middle of last season.

NQ and Dogs for the best.
Back to top Go down
JB-NQC
Guru
JB-NQC

Posts : 1058
Location : Sydney

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 3:25 pm

Parra and Penrith for the worst.

Bulldogs and Cows for the best.
Back to top Go down
Jenko
Guru
Jenko

Posts : 2372
Age : 25
Location : Sydney Reputation: █ █ █ █ █

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 11, 2010 10:34 pm

Bulldogs have done a great job, Keating, Hodkinson, PRitchard and Eastwood, Well recruited.
Back to top Go down
panthersftw
Guru
panthersftw

Posts : 3104
Location : Sydney

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeFri Nov 12, 2010 1:33 am

Bulldogs best recruited, Parra probably the worst.
Back to top Go down
James
Professional
James

Posts : 319

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeSat Nov 13, 2010 8:06 am

Oops, i misread and voted who I thought had the worst (Parra). Ahaha anyways I think Cowboys recruited the best, closely followed by the doggies.
Back to top Go down
lions10
Professional
lions10

Posts : 490
Location : The Gabba

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeSat Nov 13, 2010 9:51 am

i'd say the cowboys
Back to top Go down
RED&GREEN4EVA
Guru
RED&GREEN4EVA

Posts : 2156
Age : 40
Location : SYDNEY

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeSat Nov 13, 2010 12:28 pm

Tate will leave a big hole for the cows. I can't see them even contemplating giving tonga a release now
Back to top Go down
JB-NQC
Guru
JB-NQC

Posts : 1058
Location : Sydney

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeSat Nov 13, 2010 1:23 pm

RED&GREEN4EVA wrote:
Tate will leave a big hole for the cows. I can't see them even contemplating giving tonga a release now
Yeah i was thinking the same thing.. they'll bloody force him to play if they have too, maybe even handcuff him to the winger so he doesn't run away.
Back to top Go down
SUGEKNIGHT
Guru


Posts : 1378
Age : 28

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeTue Nov 16, 2010 9:02 am

Cowboys for me
Back to top Go down
Styletix
Guru
Styletix

Posts : 5018
Age : 32
Location : KALLANGALANGALANGA

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeTue Nov 16, 2010 10:26 am

Dogs easily best recruited. Dragons prob worst but not like they need anyone
Back to top Go down
Brad
Guru


Posts : 2276

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeTue Nov 16, 2010 10:33 am

Are the Dogs just gonna go on huge recruiting sprees every 2 years? Haha
Back to top Go down
Styletix
Guru
Styletix

Posts : 5018
Age : 32
Location : KALLANGALANGALANGA

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeTue Nov 16, 2010 10:59 am

Brad wrote:
Are the Dogs just gonna go on huge recruiting sprees every 2 years? Haha

judging by their position on the ladder it probably wouldnt be a bad idea
Back to top Go down
JB-NQC
Guru
JB-NQC

Posts : 1058
Location : Sydney

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeTue Nov 16, 2010 1:38 pm

Didn't the Dogs come up with 'bred not bought' haha.
Back to top Go down
manly4lyf
Guru
manly4lyf

Posts : 1807
Age : 27
Location : Sydney mate.

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Nov 18, 2010 3:52 am

Bulldogs seem to have money randomly to buy all these players.
I'd say Parra are the worst - not exactly the best players of their positions they've bought, but maybe a change of scenery might do some of them players some good.
Back to top Go down
zac92
Trainee
zac92

Posts : 16
Age : 28
Location : Townsville, Qld Australia

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeSat Feb 12, 2011 5:41 am

bulldogs and the warriors have the best Recuits for 2011, i'd put cowboys up there but every year they recruit a good team and always end up at the bottom of the ladder.
Back to top Go down
Brenton
Guru
Brenton

Posts : 6699

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeThu Jun 16, 2011 5:07 pm

Cowboys have been the best recruiters by miles... Dogs have been pretty average considering who they recruited
Back to top Go down
Rozza
Guru
Rozza

Posts : 8425

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeFri Jun 17, 2011 9:13 am

Don't see how anyone can argue against that statement mate. Bulldogs recruits haven't done much apart from big Tolman before he got injured. Been happy with a few of our recruits too, Maurice Blair, Adam Woolnough, Sisa Waqa have all been solid. Champion and troy Thompson have gone good but injuries have limited both of their game time. Elijah Niko is apparently killing it in reserve grade, so a good future for that guy beckons!
Back to top Go down
All_Star94
Guru
All_Star94

Posts : 1535
Age : 25
Location : Australia, NSW

Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitimeFri Jun 17, 2011 9:23 am

Rozz, I think Troy Thompson has left you guys and gone to the Sharks. His name is on the NSW Cup Sharks side.
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content




Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011   Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011 Icon_minitime

Back to top Go down
 
Best/Worst recruiters for Season 2011
Back to top 
Page 1 of 2Go to page : 1, 2  Next

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
 :: Sports Discussions :: League-
Jump to:  
Make a forum | © phpBB | Free forum support | Report an abuse | Forumotion.com